AC Plumbing

24/7 Mon to Sun

We're Open

5-Star Service ★★★★★

Gas vs Electric Hot Water Systems: Which One Saves More Money?

Gas vs Electric Hot Water Systems

Choosing the right hot water system is essential for managing household energy costs. With water heating accounting for around 25% of a home’s energy use, selecting between gas and electric can significantly impact your bills. But which system is more cost-effective in the long run?

This guide compares gas and electric hot water systems, covering installation costs, running expenses, energy efficiency, and environmental impact. Whether you’re looking to upgrade or install a new hot water system, understanding the pros and cons of each option will help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Differences Between Gas and Electric Hot Water Systems

Hot water systems work by heating water and storing it or delivering it on demand. The main difference between gas and electric systems is their energy source—natural gas or electricity—which affects performance, efficiency, and operating costs.

How a Gas Hot Water System Works

Gas hot water systems use a gas burner to heat water. There are two main types:

  • Storage Systems – These heat and store water in an insulated tank, keeping it warm until needed.
  • Continuous Flow Systems – Also called instant hot water systems, these heat water only when required, reducing energy waste.

Gas water heaters are typically connected to a natural gas supply but can also run on LPG hot water for homes without gas lines. They heat water faster than electric models and are often considered more energy-efficient over time.

How an Electric Hot Water System Works

Electric hot water systems use an element to heat the water, similar to a kettle. These systems come in two types:

  • Electric Storage Tanks – Water is heated and stored, with the system activating periodically to maintain temperature.
  • Electric Instant Hot Water Systems – These heat water as it flows through the unit, eliminating standby energy loss.

Traditional electric storage hot water systems can be costly to run, especially with continuous heating. However, modern electric systems like heat pump hot water systems offer improved efficiency by extracting heat from the air to heat water faster using less energy.

Comparing Costs: Gas vs Electric Hot Water

The cost of running a hot water system depends on factors like installation price, energy rates, and household water usage. Let’s break down the numbers.

Initial Installation Costs of Gas and Electric Hot Water Systems

When buying a hot water system, upfront costs can vary depending on the type and complexity of installation.

  • Electric hot water systems are generally cheaper to install because they don’t require a gas connection. A standard electric storage system typically costs between $500 and $2,000, while electric instant hot water systems can range from $1,000 to $2,500.
  • Gas hot water systems tend to have higher installation costs, especially if a new gas connection is needed. Prices typically range from $1,000 to $3,000, with gas continuous flow systems at the higher end.

While gas systems may be more expensive to install, they often have lower operating costs, which can lead to long-term savings.

Running Costs: Which System is More Cost-Effective?

Running costs depend on energy tariffs, water heating efficiency, and daily hot water usage.

  • Gas water heaters generally have lower running costs because gas is cheaper than electricity in many areas. However, prices fluctuate based on natural gas or LPG rates.
  • Electric systems can be more expensive to run, especially if using standard electricity tariffs. However, off-peak electricity plans and solar hot water systems can help reduce costs.

A household using 50 litres per person per day can expect the following annual running costs:

  • Gas storage hot water heater: ~$350–$700
  • Gas continuous flow system: ~$300–$600
  • Electric storage system: ~$800–$1,200
  • Electric heat pump system: ~$200–$600 (more efficient)

While gas systems are often more cost-effective, households with solar hot water systems or off-peak electricity can achieve significant savings with electric models.

Efficiency and Environmental Impact of Gas and Electric Hot Water Systems

Energy efficiency affects both costs and environmental footprint. Choosing an efficient hot water system can lower bills and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Energy Efficiency and Performance Considerations

Gas and electric systems have different efficiency levels:

  • Gas instant hot water systems are more energy-efficient than gas storage because they only heat water when needed, avoiding standby losses.
  • Electric storage systems tend to lose more heat over time, requiring more energy to maintain water temperature.
  • Heat pump hot water systems are among the most efficient options, using 60–75% less electricity than standard electric models.

Environmental Impact: Gas vs Electric Hot Water

Environmental impact depends on the energy source used to heat water:

  • Gas water heaters produce high greenhouse gas emissions due to fossil fuel combustion. Natural gas is cleaner than coal-generated electricity but still contributes to carbon pollution.
  • Electric systems can be powered by renewable energy, making them a greener choice. If powered by solar panels or a solar water system, an electric hot water heater has almost zero emissions.

For eco-conscious homeowners, choosing electric hot water with solar or heat pumps is the best option for reducing carbon footprint.

Choosing the Right Hot Water System for Your Home

Deciding between gas or electric hot water depends on your budget, energy preferences, and household needs.

Factors to Consider: Gas or Electric Hot Water?

Before choosing a hot water heater, consider the following:

  • Energy Availability – Do you have access to natural gas, or will you need an LPG hot water system? If gas isn’t available, an electric water heater might be a better option.
  • Household Size – Larger households with high hot water demands might benefit from a gas continuous flow system or instant hot water systems.
  • Running Costs – If you want to save on energy bills, check local gas and electricity tariffs before deciding.
  • Installation Costs – Gas systems can be more expensive to install, but electric storage tanks have higher running costs in the long term.

The Role of Solar and Heat Pumps in Reducing Costs

Adding solar water systems or heat pump hot water systems can make electric hot water significantly cheaper and more energy-efficient. Solar hot water systems use the sun to heat the water, reducing reliance on gas or electricity. Heat pumps work by extracting heat from the air, making them an incredibly efficient alternative.

If you already have solar panels, pairing them with an electric storage hot water system can provide free hot water, maximising energy savings.

Which Hot Water System Offers the Best Savings?

The choice between gas vs electric hot water heaters depends on installation costs, running expenses, efficiency, and energy sources.

  • Gas hot water systems are cheaper to run and heat water faster, but they produce higher greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Electric storage systems can be expensive to operate, but off-peak electricity or solar can make them cost-effective.
  • Heat pump and solar hot water systems offer the greatest savings, making them the most energy-efficient choice for the future.

For the best long-term savings, consider your home’s energy setup and whether you can incorporate renewable energy sources. If you’re unsure, AC Plumbing is here to help! Our Brisbane-based experts can assess your needs and recommend the most cost-effective hot water system for your home.

Contact us today at (07) 3088 9267 for professional advice and hot water system installation!

Enquire Online for a QUICK Response!

Why Choose Us?

  • Fully Licensed & Insured
  • Prompt Service
  • Honest, Friendly Plumbers
  • Lifetime Warranty*
  • Fixed Pricing

Reviews

steve-goodwin
Steve Goodwin

★★★★★

Contacted by Facebook 7pm to ask about fixing a concealed leak. Responded almost immediately, organised to come out next day. Turned up earlier, found the leak quickly and fixed that, as well as upgrading some taps, and replacing a water pump…
Megan Fisher

★★★★★

The AC team were great. From the very first phone call with Leanne to Andrew turning up the team were professional and friendly. Andrew made helpful observations and did a great (and fast) job of getting the job done.
Kevin Perry

★★★★★

Highly recommend. I called AC Plumbing at 11:30am to get a quote on replacing a Hot Water system. They were there in 30 minutes and the quote was very reasonable. I booked with them straight away and the job was done in under 4 hours…
Scroll to Top